Method
Two competent engines can produce different charts from the same birth data, because a dozen choices sit between the sky and a kundali and the tradition does not settle all of them. Most software hides those choices. Here they are.
Why you can check it
- 265 228 rules written from a named verse, and 37 from practice tradition, each shown with where it comes from
- 10 rules we read the verse on and set aside — we would rather show you less
- 100,000 charts every rule was measured on, so “how common this is” is a count, not a guess
What we pinned
| Choice | Ours | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Ayanamsa | Lahiri (the Chitrapaksha variant) | Picking a different family moves every chart by up to 2° — more than half a pada. |
| Lunar node | the true node | Mean and true node differ by up to 1.7°. Indian software usually prints true. |
| Houses | whole sign | The house is the sign. No cusps, no intercepted signs, no polar degeneracy. |
| Dasha year | 365.2425 days | No classical basis. A declared choice — and it moves boundaries by weeks over decades. |
| Dasha arithmetic | counted in exact days | Calendar addition and day arithmetic disagree. Also undetermined by the texts. |
| Dasha start date | the local moment of birth | A 02:00 birth falls on the previous day in UTC. That would shift every boundary by a day, forever. |
| Sunrise | the Sun's upper edge, -0.8333° | Disc and refraction move sunrise by minutes, which flips the weekday for a dawn birth. |
| Vargas | D1, D9, D10 |
There is no single formula. D10 breaks if you count continuously — a real bug we fixed. |
Derivation 1.2.0 · conventions 1.0.0. A change to any of these changes every chart, so the versions travel with your result.
What we decline, and why
| Declined | Reason |
|---|---|
| Longevity and death timing | Absolute. No tier, no request, no exception. |
| Muhurta (electional timing) | Infinitely subdividable — there is always another acceptable window, so nothing can be wrong. |
| Prashna (horary) | No natal anchor, so nothing to check a claim against. |
| Gemstone prescription | No mechanism and no counterfactual. We do state when a stone is not indicated — that is checkable. |
| Numerology | Its input is a name you can change, and a spelling that varies by transliteration. Nothing about it is falsifiable. |
| Palmistry | Requires biometric image capture, for a system with no timing structure and nothing to verify against. |
| Predictions about minors | Chart data only. No profiling of children. |
What we do not yet know
The honest part. This engine computes positions well and can prove it. What it cannot yet prove is that the classical rules built on those positions predict anything.
Rules we compute but do not show you
How precisely we can point at a source — and why most citations are chapter-level
Every rule prints a source like BPHS 46.8, which looks like a verse. For
127 of them it is not: the same locus is given for several rules at once. BPHS 46.8 is the stated source for twenty-two separate dasha rules. A shared locus is a chapter-level pointer in a verse citation's clothing — you cannot check it, and neither can we.
| Count | |
|---|---|
| Citations confirmed against the printed edition | 34 |
| Distinct loci cited | 122 |
| Loci pointing at exactly one rule | 101 |
| Rules sharing a locus with another rule | 127 |
| Rules attested as practice, with no text to check | 37 |
The last row is not a backlog. Those rules state openly that no admissible text carries them; there is no citation to verify, and counting them as unverified would pad the number with work that cannot be done.
The 21 loci carrying more than one rule
| Locus | Rules |
|---|---|
BPHS 11.16 | 36 — The lord of your 10th is in its last portion; The lord of your 10th is asleep; The lord of your 10th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 11th is in its last portion; The lord of your 11th is asleep; The lord of your 11th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 12th is in its last portion; The lord of your 12th is asleep; The lord of your 12th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 1st is in its last portion; The lord of your 1st is asleep; The lord of your 1st is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 2nd is in its last portion; The lord of your 2nd is asleep; The lord of your 2nd is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 3rd is in its last portion; The lord of your 3rd is asleep; The lord of your 3rd is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 4th is in its last portion; The lord of your 4th is asleep; The lord of your 4th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 5th is in its last portion; The lord of your 5th is asleep; The lord of your 5th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 6th is in its last portion; The lord of your 6th is asleep; The lord of your 6th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 7th is in its last portion; The lord of your 7th is asleep; The lord of your 7th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 8th is in its last portion; The lord of your 8th is asleep; The lord of your 8th is in its fourth portion; The lord of your 9th is in its last portion; The lord of your 9th is asleep; The lord of your 9th is in its fourth portion |
Horasara 21 | 17 — Your Jupiter stands in the tenth; Your Jupiter stands in the second; Your Jupiter stands in the ninth; Your Mercury stands in the first; Your Mercury stands in the tenth; Your Mercury stands in the second; Your Mercury stands in the third; Your Mercury stands in the fourth; Your Mercury stands in the fifth; Your Mercury stands in the seventh; Your Mercury stands in the eighth; Your Mercury stands in the ninth; Your Moon rises in Aries, Taurus or Cancer; Your Moon stands in the eleventh; Your Moon stands in the eighth; Your Sun stands in the sixth; Your Venus stands in the eleventh |
BPHS 11 | 12 — The lord of your 10th is in its younger years; The lord of your 11th is in its younger years; The lord of your 12th is in its younger years; The lord of your 1st is in its younger years; The lord of your 2nd is in its younger years; The lord of your 3rd is in its younger years; The lord of your 4th is in its younger years; The lord of your 5th is in its younger years; The lord of your 6th is in its younger years; The lord of your 7th is in its younger years; The lord of your 8th is in its younger years; The lord of your 9th is in its younger years |
Phaladeepika 26.12 | 10 — The Moon transiting the 1st house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 2nd house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 3rd house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 4th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 5th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 7th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 8th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 10th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 11th house counted from the natal Moon; The Moon transiting the 12th house counted from the natal Moon |
BPHS 24 | 8 — The 10th lord; The chart supports a career; The 1st lord; The chart supports personal strength and direction; The 4th lord; The chart supports a home of your own; The 7th lord; The chart supports fortune and travel |
BPHS 75.1-75.2 | 5 — Bhadra yoga; Hamsa yoga; Malavya yoga; Ruchaka yoga; Sasa yoga |
Phaladeepika 20.22 | 4 — The twelfth lord's antardasha; The sixth lord's antardasha; The eighth lord's antardasha; A vargottama mahadasha lord delivers at roughly double strength |
BPHS 34.13 | 4 — The yogakaraka in a dusthana; The yogakaraka in a kendra; The yogakaraka in a trikona; The chart supports the yogakaraka's period |
Phaladeepika 26.22 | 4 — Saturn transiting the 8th from the natal Moon; Saturn transiting the 4th from the natal Moon; Sade Sati phase 2 of 3; Sade Sati phase 3 of 3 |
BPHS 48.2-48.4 | 3 — The 5th lord's mahadasha; The sixth lord's mahadasha; The 1st lord's mahadasha |
Phaladeepika 6.57 | 3 — The 12th lord in a dusthana; The 6th lord in a dusthana; The 8th lord in a dusthana |
BPHS 27.5 | 3 — Guru in a kendra; Chandra in a kendra; Shani in a kendra |
Phaladeepika 6.14 | 2 — The Moon in a kendra from the lagna, or in its own sign; Shakat |
BPHS 47.5-47.6 | 2 — This period's lord is in its fall; This period's lord is exalted |
BPHS 53.1 | 2 — The Moon's period, with its own strong sub-period inside it; The Moon's period, with its own sub-period well placed |
BPHS 52.4 | 2 — The Sun's period, with a strong Moon inside it; The Sun's period, with the Moon well placed |
BPHS 3.49 | 2 — A planet in its fall; A planet in its exaltation sign |
BPHS 3.55-3.58 | 2 — A graha in an enemy's sign; A graha in a friend's sign |
BPHS 3.56-3.58 | 2 — The lagna lord standing in a sign whose lord is its GREAT enemy; The lagna lord standing in a sign whose lord is its GREAT friend |
BPHS 3.51 | 2 — A graha in moolatrikona; A graha in own sign |
Phaladeepika 26.18 | 2 — Jupiter transiting over the Moon itself; Jupiter transiting the fourth |
10 of the 275 rules in the corpus fail our own validation — a citation pointing at a chapter about something else, or a condition so common it cannot carry weight. They are computed, they are listed here, and they are never rendered into a reading.
Sources
Rules cite a pinned edition, chapter and verse. Where a rule is widely practised but no admissible text states it, it is marked practice tradition rather than given a citation it does not have.
Place data from GeoNames, CC-BY 4.0. Ephemeris: XALEN (Apache-2.0), validated against JPL DE440.